WHITE RIVER JUNCTION — The Hartford School Board has until Dec. 2 to pick a budget plan, and the one option that keeps every school open would save the least, district leaders said Wednesday night.
Cars were parked in makeshift spaces all over the Hartford Area Career and Technology Center lot Wednesday night, crowding it far more than at any recent school board meeting. Inside, parents, teachers and district employees packed the BEST Room, filling nearly every chair arranged in rows that stretched to the back table.
When the Hartford School District had finished its model budget presentation and the school board’s discussion started to wind down, an uncharacteristic quiet hung over the room.
Then Tim Fariel spoke up. Fariel is a member of the town selectboard and has two daughters who graduated from Hartford High School. From the podium, with his back to several dozen fellow Hartford residents, Fariel asked the school board to eschew the state mandates that have forced them into a painstaking, months-long budget reevaluation.
“I am pleading for a different path, where we have the courage to stick with what we believe in, what we need, and not suffer from a flawed fiscal system,” Fariel said.
Instead of cutting, Fariel proposed what he called a “Model T”: a new, state-of-the-art school facility for Hartford. He pointed to Somerville High School, outside Boston, as an example and said Hartford has one of the largest property tax bases in the state.
At Wednesday’s school board meeting, Superintendent Caty Sutton and her leadership team at the Hartford School District presented the budget reduction model that board member Daniel Schapira asked them to prepare at their Oct. 21 session. “Model F,” as the plan is known, envisions how the district could cut its budget without closing any schools. It offers an alternative to models C and E, two other in-depth budget-reduction proposals the district is seeking community feedback on. About 500 people have responded to the district’s survey so far, according to the presentation.
Sutton said the board needs to decide by Dec. 2 — giving it two weeks. The board will also hold a special meeting Tuesday, Nov. 24, where members may settle on a model.
In June, Gov. Phil Scott signed Act 169 into law, lowering how much a Vermont school district can spend per student before the state imposes a tax penalty. For the 2027-28 school year, the threshold drops from 118% to 115.5% of a statewide base amount, and it will keep falling in the years after. Since September, the Hartford School District has been working on its plan to cut about $5 million from its annual budget, its only option if Hartford wants to avoid that penalty.
If the district kept its current staffing and buildings, the penalty would raise education property taxes on a $300,000 home from about $3,900 this year to about $5,250 next year, and roughly double them within five years, according to the district’s presentation.
As district employees walked through their presentation, it became increasingly clear that Hartford may struggle to meet state class-size rules if it tries to reduce spending without closing a school. Neon-yellow highlights covered the Model F presentation, signaling projected class sizes that were either too small for the district’s own targets or too large for Vermont class-size requirements.
At all three elementary schools, some classes would have as few as eight students. At the middle school, the district’s only Spanish teacher already has 119 students, above the state’s limit of 100. The state will start monitoring class sizes this spring, Sutton said.
“It’s not something we can ignore,” she told the room.
Educators described a series of losses that would come with adopting Model F, like reduced child care and lost schedule flexibility. Hartford High School would lose 14 full-time positions under the model, according to the presentation.
“Hartford High School, more than any school I’ve ever seen, is student-first when it comes to building schedules,” Principal Amy Molina said.
“We take a look at what our kids want, what they need, what their future says that they need, and then we help them make really good decisions. Some of that flexibility will go away. We will end up with more schedule conflicts.”
Under Model F, the district’s prekindergarten program would be stripped to the barest of state requirements: 10 hours a week available to age-eligible children, amounting to just a few half-days of child care per week. The district now offers 32.5 hours a week, with 72 spots across its three elementary schools. The change would save about $780,000, according to the presentation. Chelsea Gray, the district’s early childhood program coordinator, said the district has not historically been able to fill half-day programs.
“It doesn’t work for families,” Gray said.
She added that not being able to fill all pre-K spots — which she said would likely happen under Model F — would drive up the district’s cost per student.
Even with all of those drawbacks, Model F would save significantly less than models C and E. Model C would close one building, preserve two elementary schools, move fifth grade to the middle school and save the district an estimated $4.7 million. Model E would keep just one elementary school, combine administrative offices with prekindergarten classrooms and save an estimated $5.1 million. Model F would keep school buildings the way they are now and save roughly $3.3 million, based on calculations by Hartford School District Finance Director Jacob Vezina.
None of the three models would bring Hartford fully under the threshold next year, according to the district’s projections. Model F would leave the district about $628 per student over the threshold, compared with about $215 under Model C and about $17 under Model E.
Vezina announced Wednesday that the expected threshold for the fiscal year ending in 2028 now looks higher than previously estimated: $16,746 per student, compared with the $16,121 the district used in its modeling. This means Hartford may not have to cut as much from its budget, though all of these numbers remain up in the air until the district receives specifics from the state. Sutton said those are expected around Dec. 1.
Because the school merger question is still on the table for Hartford under Act 170, and because, in theory, the new Legislature could change these laws when it goes into session in January, Schapira offered that the board could make a decision with the least possible impact and then see what happens. Board member Jeremy Warren, thinking about the implications for the budget, disagreed.
“We can either hope that things change and pay a severe tax penalty — which isn’t going to pass in the budget — or we can make a decision,” Warren said. He also doesn’t think school mergers would pass. Although the state mandated merger studies, local voters will ultimately decide whether school mergers happen, with votes scheduled for Town Meeting Day 2028.
“For me, it’s not Model F,” Warren continued. “Vermont has forced us to make a decision with very little data, and it sucks. But I think we need to make lemonade out of lemons.”
April Thorburn, secretary of the Hartford Education Association, the district’s teachers union, approached the podium before public comment had even begun. She urged the board not to rule out any of its current options, repeating a sentiment from earlier meetings: Look to the teachers for budget reduction ideas. Thorburn asked the board to prioritize “student-facing positions” and consider multigrade classrooms.
Sutton bookended her team’s presentation with the same sentiment she has echoed in every budget-reduction meeting so far: Nobody wants to make these budget changes. But unless the state changes its laws, the district has no choice.
Fariel, it seems, would disagree.
The school board will likely hold a special meeting Tuesday at 6 p.m. to decide on a budget plan, according to Warren.
