WHITE RIVER JUNCTION — Five years after being arrested on charges of repeated sexual assault of a child, a 38-year-old man now has a trial set for this spring, with his counsel again asking the court to suppress his original statements to police.
Wayne Miller has pleaded not guilty to 14 felony charges, including possession of child sexual abuse materials. His trial has been scheduled and canceled several times, with a slew of pretrial motions and changes in counsel that have added to the delay.
The Vermont Attorney General’s Office charged Miller, of Claremont, with two counts of aggravated repeated sexual assault of a child; four counts of sexual exploitation of a child; and eight counts of possession of child pornography, in connection with incidents the state alleges occurred while he was a Hartford resident.
Miller founded and directed Living Proof Mentoring, which connected Black mentors with Black youths across Vermont. In 2016, the Valley News reported on Miller’s journey to becoming a substance abuse counselor after recovering from addiction himself.
Speaking with police, Miller said he had no inappropriate contact with anyone he had been mentoring, a group that included young people ages 7 to 19.
In 2021, the Vermont Internet Crimes Against Children Task Force received a cyber tip from Google regarding files of suspected child sexual abuse material associated with an email account, according to an affidavit filed by Detective Matthew Raymond, a criminal investigator for the Vermont Attorney General’s Office.
After obtaining a search warrant through Windsor Superior Court, investigators discovered the IP address associated with the email was registered to Miller, whose name was also referenced in messages, the affidavit said.
Evidence stored on the account included six files that investigators say Miller created, depicting him with an 18-month-old child and recorded using a Samsung phone, along with seven child sexual abuse material files he possessed but did not create, according to the affidavit.
Although his face was not visible, police observed a tattoo in the recordings that they say matched one Miller had, along with other background details later confirmed to be his belongings.
On Dec. 8, 2021, a team of police searched Miller’s home with a federal warrant. He had just returned from the hospital, where he had sought psychiatric treatment, he said.
The affidavit says police told Miller he was “not under arrest, was not in [police] custody, did not have to talk with [police] and could stop talking at any time.”
Confronted with information about the email account and the evidence associated with it, Miller told officers that the files belonged to him and provided them a password to his phone and photo vault app, the affidavit said.
Police then asked Miller whether they could get the case file to show him the material, and he agreed, according to the affidavit. They first showed him the child sexual abuse videos believed to involve others.
“Wayne Miller agreed these had all been in his account and shook his head yes when asked if they were all real child pornography,” the affidavit stated.
Miller also identified himself and the child as the people in the child sexual abuse videos he is accused of creating, the affidavit said.
A federal case in U.S. District Court in Vermont opened in December 2021 but closed in May 2022, allowing the state to prosecute Miller. An indictment associated with a federal charge of producing child pornography was also dismissed.
The case has since remained pending in Windsor Superior Court, where at least three of Miller’s attorneys have asked to withdraw, the Valley News reported in October 2025.
On Nov. 3, the defense asked the court to suppress Miller’s original statements to law enforcement in 2021, despite a previous motion to do so having been denied. When a suppression motion is granted, details provided by a defendant to police generally cannot be considered as evidence against them at trial.
The court initially determined that, since Miller was not in custody at the time of the home search, police weren’t required to read him his Miranda rights before questioning him.
Now, Miller’s attorney, Joshua Stern, has argued that the defendant may have felt he had no choice but to provide information to police.
Stern asked that the court consider Miller’s perspective as a Black man as a possible reason why he felt obligated to answer police questioning, pointing out that “the relationship between Black citizens and law enforcement can affect how police authority is reasonably perceived.”
Stern went on to say that Miller was questioned in a confined physical setting, with multiple officers present, and at least one officer had been armed and was positioned between the defendant and the exit.
As a result, Miller may have believed he had no reasonable choice but to answer their questions, despite it being within his legal right to end the encounter, Stern said, calling for a hearing and to suppress Miller’s statements.
The court granted the prosecution, represented by Nicholas Battey of the Vermont Attorney General’s Office, an extension until Dec. 14 to respond to Stern’s motion.
Jury selection in Miller’s trial is scheduled to begin April 26, 2027, Judge Elizabeth Mann said at a Tuesday status conference. He has been held without bail at the Southern State Correctional Facility in Springfield since 2021.
