CLAREMONT — Eighteen months after the New Hampshire Department of Environmental Services denied an application for a large-scale construction and demolition operation at Recycling Services Inc. on Industrial Boulevard, the appeals process before the state’s Waste Management Council drags on.

DES denied the application in May 2025, finding that the operation would obstruct traffic flow, that letting trucks queue at RSI’s facility across the road would interfere with the operation of that facility and that the company’s request to waive a 50-foot setback requirement did not meet the criteria in the state’s administrative rules.

In its latest rulings, council hearing officer Mary Maloney set several deadlines for early 2027 after RSI requested more time.

“The appellant requests additional time to complete discovery, review exchanged information, confer on stipulations of fact and finalize witness and exhibit lists,” Maloney’s order reads. DES agreed to the requested continuance.

Maloney set the final prehearing conference on the appeal for Feb. 11, 2027, with a hearing date of Feb. 18.

RSI, which is owned by Acuity Management of Methuen, Massachusetts, made six claims, or “grounds,” in its June 23, 2025, appeal, alleging the decision by DES that May was “unlawful and unreasonable.”

In two of the claims in the appeal, RSI said the DES findings “that traffic flow would be obstructed” and that allowing trucks “to queue at its other facility [on the opposite side of the road] would interfere with the proper operation of that facility” were “based upon an improper interpretation and application of the New Hampshire Code of Administrative Rules.”

DES also denied a waiver of the 50-foot setback requirement because it said the request did not meet the criteria for the waiver in the state’s administrative rules.

DES did not cite as a reason for the denial the strong local opposition to the proposal expressed by residents at a March 2025 DES public hearing. About 400 residents attended the hearing at the Claremont Opera House, many urging the department to deny the application because of the likelihood of excessive noise, dust and other potential environmental and health hazards, including groundwater, soil and wetlands pollution from lead. Additionally, they said trucks carrying 500 tons of debris daily would lead to costly repairs to the city’s infrastructure.

In April, DES filed a motion to dismiss three other claims, and on July 27, Maloney ruled in DES’s favor and dismissed grounds 4, 5 and 6.

Ground 4 said DES “selectively interpreted and enforced rules” against RSI but not against similarly situated parties and therefore violated RSI’s right to equal protection under the law.

In dismissing the claim, Maloney said RSI “has not asserted sufficient facts or legal authority to support the claim.”

Ground 5 said DES failed in its constitutional duty to assist citizens to comply with the laws it administers “by denying RSI’s application based upon grounds it did not bring to its attention, prior to the denial.”

Maloney said in her order that DES notified RSI of the problems with queuing and traffic on the road, but its amended application did not address those problems.

Ground 6 alleged the denial was partly because DES wanted to subject RSI’s project to the Solid Waste Evaluation Committee to avoid making a locally controversial decision.

Several years ago, RSI applied to the city for a permit modification to allow up to 2,500 tons of construction and demolition material a week to be trucked to 43 Industrial Blvd., which sits across the road from the recycling company’s main facility at 38 Industrial Blvd., where it processes metal and cardboard. The company proposed building a structure at 43 Industrial Blvd. on a 1-acre parcel where there is a rail siding and pouring a concrete tipping floor. The debris would be dumped on the floor, sorted for recyclables and the rest loaded onto rail cars for shipment to Ohio.

The city twice denied RSI’s application to modify the company’s 1987 recycling permit, saying RSI was proposing a transfer station operation, which is not a permitted use in the Industrial District.

Acuity has sued the city in Superior Court over its actions, but the suit has been held in abeyance and likely will not proceed until the state’s Waste Management Council rules on the appeal.

Over RSI’s objection, the council has also granted several residents partial intervenor status in the appeal. The residents, who either live or own property near the proposed operation, said that in addition to bringing unwanted noise, dust, odor and litter to the city and impacting soils and groundwater, the operation would also adversely affect their quality of life, property values, enjoyment of property and future investment in the city.

In a May 4 ruling, Maloney said “justice will be served” by granting the petitioners intervention on a “limited basis” because of their participation in the permitting process. They will receive copies of all pleadings and orders and notice of hearings.

They will also be permitted to file “one unified Hearing Memorandum at the end of the case, no longer than 10 pages in length, that shall be limited to providing legal arguments that address the issues raised in this appeal,” Maloney wrote.

All filings in the case are available by searching Recycling Services at https://www4.des.state.nh.us/Legal/index.html.

Patrick O’Grady can be reached at pogclmt@gmail.com.

Patrick O'Grady covers Claremont and Newport for the Valley News. He can be reached at pogclmt@gmail.com