Dartmouth’s Standards

The recent action of Dartmouth’s Alumni Council regarding the Black Family Visual Arts Center purports to be based on Dartmouth’s “standards of integrity, ethical behavior, and responsible leadership.” As a proud 1960 graduate of the College I find the Council’s actions to be in direct conflict with those standards. The bases for the action are “severe allegations of misconduct.” In my Dartmouth, and subsequent law school, education I was taught that acting on mere allegations was not a sign of integrity, ethical behavior or responsible leadership. In this case the sole connection established between Mr. Black and the odious Mr. Epstein is business transactions. Legal filings based on allegations of Black’s connection to any of Epstein’s sexual or morally reprehensible actions have been dismissed. Nonetheless, a current student (apparently echoing similar thoughts of many students) pressured the Alumni Council to call for removal of the Black name from the Visual Arts Center because Black is an “accused sexual assaulter” even though no person has claimed that Black sexually assaulted them, was aware of Epstein’s sexual assaults or participated in any of his “social” activities.” I do not want Dartmouth’s reputation and its principles and values to be sullied by acting on unsupported allegations of students and the Alumni Council who themselves appear to be acting at odds with those principles and values. Ironically, the current issue of the Dartmouth Alumni Magazine (DAM) includes a long and thoughtful review of the actions of President Ernest Martin Hopkins who resisted the alumni outcry that the remarkable and artistically exceptional Orozco Mural should be destroyed because it was created by a “modernist, a Mexican and some kind of ‘Red.'” DAM Nov/Dec 2026 at 41. President Hopkins’ resistance to prejudice-based pressure from alumni reflects the “standards of integrity, ethical behavior and responsible leadership” of Dartmouth that I embrace and not the demands of students and the Alumni Council that condemn a family based on unproven allegations of sexual misconduct. The College can do better than join this kind of “cancel culture” condemnation by innuendo. If there is a basis to remove the name or statue or plaque honoring any person proven to be unworthy of the honor, or person holding a position of College leadership including Trustee or Alumni Council membership similarly unworthy, the College should take action. Students who care about these issues should undertake a full investigation of all such persons and urge action when they find real evidence. The Black Family has not been proven to be unworthy of having its name on the Visual Arts Center. “This is not the droid they are looking for.”

Anthony Roisman, Weathersfield