WHITE RIVER JUNCTION — At the heart of the selectboard’s discussion Thursday night was the tension between one truth: Hartford needs more money to help people in crisis, and one possibility: asking neighboring towns for money might encourage them to outsource their aid initiatives to Hartford even more than they already do.

To board member Miranda Dupre, both of these situations are already reality. So why not ask for the money?

“What we fear is going to happen is already happening,” she said. “Are we going to be sitting here, six months from now, having not gone for this money … think[ing] of a million ways we could use it?”

On Nov. 10, Hartford Selectboard Chair Ida Griesemer proposed the town include requests for $20,000 from Lebanon, Hanover and Norwich in its FYE 2028 budget. Before coming to a decision, several board members wanted the perspectives of Hartford public safety officials. The board held a special meeting to discuss the requests Thursday evening.

At Hartford Town Hall, they heard briefly from Police Chief Constance Kelley and continued their discussion about the requests. They once again decided to punt their decision to later on in budget season, unable to come to a conclusion about the amount of money to ask for and how, exactly, they should distribute it.

Selectboard members examined the best practices for this theoretical fund from all angles. Ashley Andreas proposed lowering the request to $5,000 per town. Erik Krauss offered to make the money an “insurance policy,” paid back if left unused. Mary Erdei seemed opposed to it entirely.

Erdei began the board’s discussion on the issue, continuing the argument she made Nov. 10 that the homelessness, mental health and substance abuse issues in the Upper Valley require a long-term solution, not a short-term one. Instead of the funding request, she pushed for a multi-town consortium that would include leaders from local businesses, churches and social service organizations and task them with discussing the broader issue of Upper Valley people in crisis on a “perfectly voluntary” basis.

Erdei said in preparation for this discussion, she spoke to Will Towne, the executive director of the Upper Valley Haven. She said he had received “blowback” in recent meetings about the idea to ask other towns for funding. But Towne told the Valley News Friday he doesn’t necessarily oppose the idea — he simply doesn’t think it will solve everything.

“I think it’s just the start of a conversation about how we can collaborate to address an issue that is larger than one town and one area and, frankly, one state,” he said. “I don’t really have a stance on what the selectboard is doing.”

To other Hartford Selectboard members, Griesemer’s letter doesn’t mean these bigger, more drawn-out conversations can’t happen. Krauss, the vice chair, raised a point of inquiry when Erdei was done, asking the board to table the bigger-picture discussion and attack the question at hand: Should the selectboard send the request letters?

Hartford’s police chief gave her perspective, explaining the only concrete way the police department could improve its outreach efforts would be by hiring additional officers. 

“There may be some unintended consequences,” Kelley said. “I caution both sides of it.”

She told a story about one of her officers picking up a family at night and paying for their hotel room out-of-pocket.

Griesemer made the point that these crisis funds could be used to reimburse an officer in a situation like that. But by the end of the discussion, the selectboard chair said she was reluctant to send the letter before further budget discussion.

Only one community member attended Hartford’s special meeting Thursday. Kim Souza, owner of the downtown store Revolution and a former selectboard member, said the best use of these funds would be a mobile outreach van, something Hartford PD has already invested in with a $30,000 allowance from the Opioid Settlement Grant. According to Lt. Will Furnari, who chimed in on Zoom, that amount is likely not enough for the project. But he echoed the sentiment that using money from other towns might cause further liability for a mobile outreach program, especially if it had to cross state borders.

“We want to do the right thing, but we don’t want to be the only ones doing the right thing,” Andreas said.

Sophie Levenson can be reached at slevenson@vnews.com or 603-727-3216.