Contributor Wayne Gersen in West Lebanon, N.H., on April 12, 2019. (Valley News - Geoff Hansen) Copyright Valley News. May not be reprinted or used online without permission. Send requests to permission@vnews.com.
Contributor Wayne Gersen in West Lebanon, N.H., on April 12, 2019. (Valley News - Geoff Hansen) Copyright Valley News. May not be reprinted or used online without permission. Send requests to permission@vnews.com.

Now that New Hampshire voters have changed the balance of power at the state level, Democrats have a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to address New Hampshire’s over-reliance on property taxes. By doing so, they could fulfill the state’s constitutional requirement to provide all students in the state with an “adequate” education and address longstanding infrastructure deficiencies.

After the Claremont decisions in the 1990s, where courts determined that the State needed to raise additional revenue to fully and equitably fund “adequate” public schools, legislatures ignored this decision. A subsequent lawsuit by the Conval schools in 2023 reaffirmed it, and the ruling judge estimated the state needed to raise a minimum of roughly $500 million per year to fulfill its constitutional mandate to underwrite public education. In addition, a pending case asserts that the state should be responsible for offsetting costs districts incur for special education, arguing that such costs should be included in the “adequate education” definition. If that decision stands, states would be required to raise an additional $800 million per year. Finally, according to the most recent estimates from the New Hampshire Department of Education, the state needs $650 million to address a backlog of school construction projects.

But the state’s infrastructure deficiencies are hardly limited to schools. According to the 2025 report card issued by the American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), New Hampshire’s dams on average are more than 100 years old, many drinking water systems are exceeding their intended service life and much of the wastewater collection infrastructure, some of which dates to the 1870s, is in poor or failing condition. Only about 35% of the rail network can handle industry-standard carloads. Also, the ASCE report notes that 34% of the state’s roads are in poor or fair condition and “driving on deteriorated roads costs each Granite State motorist an average of $530 per year in extra vehicle repairs and operating expenses.” The New Hampshire Department of Transportation forecasts “a multi-hundred million to multi-billion-dollar funding shortfall for its upcoming 10-year project pipeline.”

There was a time states could look to the federal government for assistance in these kinds of projects, but that day is over. Instead, the recently passed “One Big Beautiful Budget Bill Act” (OBBBA) downshifts responsibilities to the states and cuts federal funding tied to those programs. Because of OBBBA, New Hampshire’s SNAP revenues will be cut by $4 million in 2027 and $6 million to $7 million per year thereafter. New Hampshire will also lose Medicaid revenues of $2.3 billion over the next 10 years because of an estimated 23,000 citizens being disenrolled when work requirements go into effect, work requirements the state will implement and administer. To make matters worse, it is likely that the disenrollments will increase the cost of health insurance premiums across the board and challenge the viability of small rural hospitals. Finally, delays and budget cuts by the Executive Branch are resulting in an estimated loss of  $602 million in federal funding to New Hampshire over a wide range of programs.

The incoming legislature is inheriting a budget challenge that cannot be met by reducing “waste, fraud and abuse,” “improving efficiency” or instituting local budget caps. Nor can the funding gap be closed by the elimination of EFAs ($68 million), the reinstitution of the business profits tax ($90 million) or a 15% tax on marijuana, which at most will generate $57.8 million if it is legalized. If the legislature hopes to pay the bills that are due, it needs to increase revenues by hundreds of millions, not tens of millions.

Here are three revenue ideas that meet the New Hampshire Constitution’s requirement that prohibits progressive taxes AND raise the hundreds of millions needed to meet the state’s existing needs, infrastructure needs and downshifts:

  • Andru Volinsky’s 3-3 Tax Savings Plan, which could generate approximately $2 billion per year in gross state revenue: $1 billion from a 3% flat state income tax and $1 billion from a $3-per-$1,000 statewide property tax. According to a model by the Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy (ITEP), the 3-3 proposal would use the additional $2 billion in state revenue to alleviate roughly $1.64 billion in local school property taxes and increase state education aid. Since Volinsky’s plan proposes a uniform 3% rate paired with large cost-of-living deductions that limit the taxes levied on those who can afford it least, it meets the State’s constitutional standard.
  • A uniform 7.65% marginal income tax for those earning over $192,300, the 2027 Social Security cut-off figure. This would generate roughly $1.43 billion per year after behavioral adjustments.  
  • A flat 10.3% tax for individual income over $360,000 that mirrors one recently supported by nearly 60% of the voters in California. In California, the revenue from this tax is earmarked for public education, with 89% of the money going to K-12 public schools and 11% to community colleges. In New Hampshire, such a tax would generate roughly $1.3 billion per year after accounting for taxpayer behavioral responses. Such an infusion of state funding in public education would substantially reduce the burden on property taxes.

Having lived in New Hampshire for over 25 years, I realize that broad-based taxes are an anathema and low business taxes provide “the New Hampshire advantage.” But given the costs the state faces, the fact that voters clearly want relief from property taxes, and the analyses above that low business taxes give New Hampshire an advantage over other states, it strikes me that an income tax on the top 4% to 6% of earners is a revenue solution worth considering.

If not now, when?

Wayne Gersen is a retired public school administrator. He lives in Etna.