WHITE RIVER JUNCTION — Two accomplices to a deadly attempted robbery in Hartford last year have received six-month prison sentences on the condition that they both cooperate with the state in the upcoming trial of the man who allegedly pulled the trigger.
The surviving victim, Jessica Lemay, 37, wouldn’t have lived if not for her boyfriend, David Labrecque, 65, who died trying to save her, according to court documents.
In Windsor Superior Court on Friday afternoon, Michelle Mullins, 47, whose husband was sentenced in September for his role in the incident, turned to Lemay, sitting in the gallery, and tearfully apologized.
“I know you think I don’t care or feel,” Mullins said. “But I want you to know I am so sorry.”
Lemay didn’t look at her.
When given her chance to speak, Lemay felt no less bitter than she did at the September sentencing of Mullins’ husband, Jeffrey Mullins, 47, when she said, “The punishment doesn’t fit the crime.” She repeated the sentiment on Friday.
“Every day, I wake up in the aftermath,” Lemay said, still struggling to cope with not just the loss of her boyfriend and the injuries she sustained but also the plea agreements, which she said she didn’t support, in the Mullins cases. “I was in the wrong place at the wrong time. So was Dave.”
The shooting occurred in the early morning hours of Aug. 21, 2025, outside a residence on Verna Court in White River Junction. The alleged gunman was 31-year-old Demetrius Drew of New Haven, Connecticut, according to court documents.
Lemay suffered multiple gunshot wounds from a man whose face was covered with a bandana, she previously told the Valley News. After the first shot, Labrecque came running from the house to save her.
The man in the bandana, later identified by police as Drew, shot Labrecque in the chest as he charged, then stood over him and shot him in the back, Lemay said.
Lemay and Labrecque shared a home in Canaan. He was a mechanic, and she was trying to start her own house cleaning business.
“The light was gone from his eyes,” Lemay, who was shot in the abdomen and hand, previously told the Valley News. “He was gone.”
The initial charges the Mullinses faced were aiding in the commission of first-degree murder, which carries a penalty of up to life in prison, and a charge of accessory to attempted assault and robbery, with a penalty of up to 10 years.
In a November 2025 plea agreement, Jeffrey Mullins agreed to enter a guilty plea to felony accessory to attempted assault and robbery with a sentence of six to 10 years suspended to six months and 10 years of probation.
Windsor Superior Judge Elizabeth Mann accepted and ordered the sentence in September 2026.
Michelle Mullins pleaded guilty to the same lesser charge in a May plea agreement, also stipulating a sentence of six to 10 years suspended to six months but with 12 years of probation.
The court also accepted her sentence.
“The negotiated outcome here is less than we might expect to see in the average case,” Mann conceded.
However, as prosecutor Nicholas Battey with the Vermont Attorney General’s Office also stressed at both sentencing hearings, Mann noted the court-sealed cooperation agreements between the state and the Mullinses as witnesses for the conviction of Drew are key to each reduced sentence.
Additionally, if the Mullinses fail to cooperate, provisions included in their plea deals state that the remaining count of aiding in the commission of first-degree murder, which has been dismissed, is subject to being refiled.
Mullins is ordered by the court to report to Chittenden Regional Correctional Facility in South Burlington on Tuesday no later than noon. She has 141 days of credit for time served toward the six months.
According to court records, she also has a pending case of felony drug possession in Grafton County, New Hampshire, stemming from an incident in Lebanon which also involved her husband Jeffrey Mullins and occurred two months before the Hartford shooting.
Drew isn’t scheduled for a trial until next year, court records show.
Following the shooting, Drew entered not guilty pleas to charges of first-degree murder, second-degree murder, attempted second-degree murder, aggravated assault with a deadly weapon and attempted assault and robbery with a weapon.
According to the affidavit in the case, Drew told police he wasn’t even in the state on Aug. 21.
However, police obtained footage of him on Lily Pond Road, a couple miles from Verna Court, at around 6 a.m., about three hours after the shooting, according to court records.
Drew has handwritten several motions from Southern State Correctional Facility in Springfield, Vermont, to Mann, making multiple requests of the court, including a new arraignment and bail hearing, along with the impeachment of a witness.
Mann ruled in late October that no further review of his requests will be conducted unless his motions are submitted through his attorney.
Drew also has a pending civil case against Southern State Correctional Facility, alleging staff misconduct related to a urine drug test in September 2025.
In the Hartford shooting case, he is scheduled for a pre-trial conference and a jury draw in February 2027, court records show.
For Jessica Lemay, the wounds from August of last year tear open each time she has to go back to court, she said on Friday.
“I have to come back here and go in front of the court,” Lemay said. “I didn’t sign up for this.”
