Sage McGinley-Smith
Sage McGinley-Smith

CONCORD — For years, Hanover High possessed the girls hockey program that not only overwhelmed foes with its skills but with its numbers as well. John Dodds could annually count on full 20-player rosters, rolling three or four lines against teams that often struggled to counter with two.

No more.

Limited to two lines by a smaller roster and under pressure seemingly the entire night, the Marauders fell to Bishop Guertin, 5-4 in overtime, in an NHIAA Division I semifinal at Everett Arena on Tuesday night. The Cardinals (16-0-0) let four one-goal leads get away, but Kathryn Simpson made the fifth one the last by converting out of a goalmouth scramble at 5:46 of the extra session.

“We’re not normally a two-line team,” Dodds said. “We were missing a couple of people, and that might have affected us a little bit. We didn’t have quite the jump that I normally expected.”

Danielle Rudd, Lily Seelig, Maeve Lee and Natalie Morhun scored for Hanover. Sage McGinley-Smith assisted on three of the goals.

With BG’s defensemen pinching tight to the wing boards and pressing inside the blue line, Hanover (12-2-0) struggled to get the puck out of its half of the ice all night. The Cardinals enjoyed a 12-4 advantage in shots in the opening period but left with only a 1-1 tie at the buzzer — and it should have been worse.

What-the-heck throws to the net accounted for the two goals about two minutes apart. Guertin’s Julie McLaughlin whipped a shot from the right boards through the legs of Hanover netminder Rebekah Rudd (29 saves) at 11:45.

Danielle Rudd returned the favor at 13:56, going five-hole on BG netminder Sarah King (10 saves) from the right hash.

An errant Guertin pass in the Hanover zone nearly ended in disaster for the Cards at period’s end. Lee and McGinley-Smith broke in alone on King from the Marauder blue line, and King made a spectacular left-pad save when Lee tried a backhand flip at the crease edge.

“It was like the last time we played them: One team would get a goal, and the other one would come back,” Dodds said. “It was back and forth, between evenly matched teams.”

A livelier Hanover greeted the second period — a ping of a goalpost behind King off the stick of McGinley-Smith after 10 seconds the punctuation — but a series of alternating goals left BG holding a 4-3 edge at the intermission.

Rebekah Rudd poked a loose puck away from a teammate at the crease edge right to Simpson, who converted at 2:34. Hanover leveled 75 seconds later, Seelig lofting a left-point puck that eluded the screened King.

BG regained the lead and lost it again in the span of five minutes. Brooke Yarbroudy scored out of a scramble at 6:49, which Lee answered on an unassisted solo rush at 11:57. Just when it look like honors even at the horn, the Cardinals’ Jenna Lynch potted a Simpson behind-the-net feed with 53.7 seconds left for Guertin’s fourth lead of the night.

It almost held. With the Hanover goalie on the bench and the Marauders pressing, McGinley-Smith threw a puck from the left corner that caught Morhun’s skate and slipped between King’s pads with 30.6 seconds left in regulation.

Hanover forced an icing off the overtime faceoff, nearly winning the game moments later. Just 25 seconds in, McGinley-Smith flipped a puck that bounced short of King, hit a defender, trickled through the goalie’s pads and exited just wide of the left post.

Simpson didn’t miss 5½ minutes later. Yarbroudy and Jill Scanlon shoveled the puck into traffic, and the conversion sent the Cardinals racing out in celebration.

“I think that they’re just pretty quick and they didn’t give us a lot of space,” Dodds said. “(The winner) was at least two or three shots, rebounds, and we just didn’t have enough energy to get them out.”

■

Stick Checks: Forward Rory Seelig (quarantine) and goalie Katie Smith (illness) missed the game for Hanover. The speedy Seelig usually forms a third line with double-shifting wings, Dodds said. … Despite occasional physical play, including McGinley-Smith steamrolling a BG defender along the boards in the third period, the game went without a penalty called. … Tucker Garrity-Hanchett and Briland Laycock assisted Dodds this season. The former coached the Colby-Sawyer College women’s club hockey program last winter. The latter is a one-time standout Hanover forward (88-48—136 in two seasons) who would have been a junior with the Williams College women’s this year team had the Ephs season not been canceled by COVID back in October. … The Marauders’ sole regular-season loss came to the Cardinals in Hudson, N.H., on Feb. 24, 7-4. Hanover gave up just eight other goals in its remaining games, only one other time surrendering more than one (6-3 win over Concord at Campion Rink on Feb. 6). … Hanover graduates Rebekah Rudd, McGinley-Smith and Morhun.

Greg Fennell can be reached at gfennell@vnews.com or 603-727-3226.