CONCORD – A panel with the state attorney discipline system has unanimously recommended disbarment for a Lebanon attorney who confessed to police that he stole roughly half a million dollars of client funds.
At a September hearing in Concord Probate Court, the panel found clear and convincing evidence that Stephen Girdwood violated numerous rules of professional conduct.
Girdwood misappropriated the entirety of $487,000 in funds he held on a client’s behalf in the divorce case of former Enfield residents Keith and Athena Nicholson, according to an investigation by the Attorney Discipline Office, which was presented at the hearing by Chief Disciplinary Counsel Sara Greene. Girdwood took the funds out of escrow for personal expenses and investing in a sports and entertainment venture in Florida, without client authorization.
The investigation also uncovered evidence that Girdwood misappropriated funds of other clients and repeatedly commingled client funds over several years.
Ahead of the hearing, Girdwood, through his attorney, invoked his 5th Amendment Right against self-incrimination, acknowledging the adverse inference that could be drawn by doing so.
The hearing proceeded with an offer of proof by Greene, giving Girdwood an opportunity to object or offer counter-evidence for the panel’s consideration. He did neither.
The facts were therefore weighed as uncontested, the panel stated in a memorandum recommending disbarment on Wednesday.
In January of this year, the New Hampshire Supreme Court issued an interim suspension order against Girdwood, which was followed, in July, by a reciprocal order of suspension by the Vermont Supreme Court, the Valley News previously reported. Girdwood became a licensed attorney in both states in 1993.
The panel, while deciding its recommendation, considered any factors in Girdwood’s favor.
“Certainly, the most salient mitigating factor is Mr. Girdwood’s lack of prior criminal history and his voluntary report and confession of his wrongdoing to the Lebanon Police Department,” the panel wrote in its memorandum.
Girdwood confessed in January to Lebanon Police to stealing all of the Nicholsons’ escrowed funds, along with other client funds.
He explained that he used funds in his practice’s trust account to reimburse other clients, pay for personal expenses and invest in Frozen Lake Sports and Entertainment, a company he incorporated in Wyoming in 2020 with an Orlando, Fla.-address, according to the police report.
Lebanon Police subsequently opened a criminal investigation into Girdwood, before turning the case over to the FBI.
However, the panel stated in its memorandum, his clean criminal record and police admission “do not greatly weigh in his favor in light of the breadth of Mr. Girdwood’s deliberate, knowing and dishonest acts, which occurred on multiple occasions for his own benefit and resulted in devastating injury to the Nicholsons, and an overall adverse impact upon public confidence in the legal profession.”
The Nicholsons suffered more than financial injury, the panel noted.
Athena Nicholson, 65, testified before the panel that as a result of Girdwood’s theft of her $195,000 of the escrowed funds, her emotional health severely regressed, adding that she is disabled and unable to work.
Keith Nicholson, 64, experienced a breakout of psoriasis and chest pain, further testifying that he was placed on blood thinners and thought he had had a heart attack in the wake of losing his $292,000 portion of the escrowed funds.
Both also spent thousands in legal fees and are seeking reimbursement through the New Hampshire Supreme Court Public Protection Fund.
The fund could pay out claims once the Supreme Court issues a disbarment order, the Valley News previously reported.
The panel, along with recommending disbarment, also stated that he should have to reimburse the attorney discipline system for all costs associated with the investigation and the prosecution.
Greene estimated the total cost of prosecution to be around $4,600, she said in an email.
While the hearing panel has now made official sanctioning recommendations, Greene explained that nothing is final until the case is reviewed by the attorney discipline system’s Professional Conduct Committee and then the Supreme Court.
“That could take a few more months,” Greene said.
