CORINTH — Police say a 24-year-old woman recklessly endangered her partner before he died of a gunshot wound to the head on Valentine’s Day.

The Orange County State’s Attorney’s office filed a Tuesday memorandum claiming that, amid a domestic dispute, Donna Guillette set a firearm down between herself and 25-year-old Jeremy Kawalec, knowing he was at risk of committing suicide.

“She presented a firearm into a volatile situation and essentially placed the loaded and unsecured firearm in front of the person telling her to shoot him,” Attorney Colin Seaman wrote.

The memorandum was in response to an order by Judge Rory Thibault stating that, based on the police evidence, it’s unclear how Guillette’s actions reflect a disregard of risk to Kawalec’s life.

Guillette’s actions show a “gross deviation from a law-abiding citizen,” Seaman wrote.

Guillette pleaded not guilty to the misdemeanor charge of reckless endangerment at a Wednesday arraignment. On the same day, Thibault ruled that enough probable cause existed to move forward with the charges against her.

“All we want is justice for Jeremy,” Kawalec’s grandfather, Ron Riopel, told the Valley News.

The investigation

On Feb. 14, Vermont State Police responded to a 911 call reporting that a man sustained a possible gunshot wound to the head in the living room of a Richardson Road home, with a woman located in the bathroom.

Trooper Ryan Underhill found Kawalec unresponsive on the floor with a handgun positioned between his legs. EMS arrived and pronounced him dead.

At the scene, Guillette told troopers that, on the drive home from dinner with family, she and Kawalec had an argument that continued at home.

Both had been drinking, and the medical examiner later determined Kawalec’s blood alcohol level was .086. Police determined Guillette’s was .158 nearly two hours after the incident occurred, almost twice the legal limit to drive.

While Kawalec had her phone, she said she retrieved her handgun from her purse out of fear for her safety, and Kawalec said “shoot me,” Guillette claimed.

Guillette told police she then placed the firearm on top of a heater in the narrow hallway between them, and said that Kawalec picked it up. The two began struggling over the gun, which went off during the altercation. She heard it discharge twice and upon seeing significant blood, fled to the bathroom, police wrote in their affidavit.

Detective Lt. Kyle Decker, who filed the affidavit, noted an undisturbed layer of dust on top of the heater where Guillette said she placed the gun, he wrote. He also observed Kawalec’s injuries as a gunshot wound to the left side of the head, three to four inches above his ear, and another to the right side of his head, just above the ear.

The day after the shooting on Feb. 15, police said they were investigating the suspicious death of a man found unresponsive at a Richardson Road home. The incident arose from a dispute involving two people who knew each other, police said at the time.

On Feb. 17, police identified the deceased man as Kawalec and announced that the cause of death was a “gunshot wound during an altercation,” though the manner of death was undetermined. Police also stated that the death was no longer considered suspicious.

In an interview with the Valley News on Feb. 18, Guillette described Kawalec as a Marine veteran in mental crisis, whom she tried to stop from taking his life.

Six months later, state police moved to charge Guillette with reckless endangerment for having introduced a gun into the situation knowing Kawalec was expressing intentions of self-harm.

Riopel said he doesn’t believe his grandson was suicidal. He described him as “very smart,” outgoing and adored by the people around him.

“He made everybody smile and laugh,” said Riopel. “He was just a good-natured kid.”

The shooting

The evening began with Kawalec and Guillette going out to dinner with Guillette’s mother and uncle. Guillette made a point to mention Kawalec did not get her a Valentine’s Day gift. The conversation made Kawalec upset, and he “became grumpy and quiet,” Rebecca Guillette, Donna’s mother, told police.

They had been dating for about three months, and had considered having a child together, according to court documents. Earlier on Valentine’s Day, they went horseback riding and had “such a great day,” Guillette told the Valley News In February.

That night, the argument turned toward their plans to a baby, according to court documents.

At one point in the evening, Kawalec said he didn’t want to bring a child into the relationship if they weren’t getting along, according to a video recorded on a phone that was obtained by police.

At one point, while Kawalec was on the phone with Donna’s mother, Donna went out the back door to his truck. Kawalec followed and they struggled. Police found a clump of Guillette’s hair in the truck, according to court records. Kawalec’s autopsy revealed a fresh bite mark on his shoulder that police believe came from Guillette.

As the argument continued, Guillette told police that she went into her bedroom, removed a pistol from her purse and had it down by her side as she exited the room due to being scared. Kawalec approached her in the hallway and told her to shoot him when he observed the gun, she said.

Guillette told police that Kawalec grabbed the firearm right as soon as she set it down. She specified that he grabbed it with his left hand and had full control of it from that point forward.

As Guillette attempted to get the gun back, the two stumbled backwards into the living room. They fell on the floor, and she was on top of Kawalec, with her head near his chest. Shortly after they fell, Guillette heard a shot ringing in her left ear and she jumped back and yelled, she told police.

She heard a second shot and “observed blood everywhere,” before grabbing her phone and running into the bathroom to call for help, she said.

Speaking with police, Guillette said that Kawalec struggled with PTSD and suicidal ideation throughout the three months they had been dating and “constantly stated he wanted to kill himself,” the affidavit said.

Police interviewed a friend, Joshua Cole, who knew the couple and confirmed he also believed that Kawalec was suicidal based on previous conversations with him.

Cole later said in an August interview that he had gotten into his own verbal dispute with Guillette before she and Kawalec started dating, causing him to leave his own residence. Upon return, he saw bullet holes in the ceiling that she admitted to making.

“Cole advised he did not think she intended to hurt anyone; it was more to disrespect him than anything,” the affidavit said.

In another interview on Feb. 26, Guillette told police that after she put the gun down, Kawalec indicated he was going to shoot himself, which prompted her to yell at him to stop and attempt to get the gun back.

Authorities indicated that certain details of Guillette’s testimony changed over multiple interviews. For example, Seaman’s memorandum noted that Guillette initially said Kawalec smashed a coffee pot before she took out the gun, then later said he did so while asking her to shoot him.

Riopel believes that Guillette had more of a role in Kawalec’s death than police cited her for, but said the family is satisfied with the reckless endangerment charge if there is not enough evidence for something stronger, such as manslaughter.

Riopel said he felt like her story didn’t add up.

“Because the narrative has changed so many times, that’s what’s causing the heartache,” said Riopel.

Guillette did not respond by deadline to a Thursday message. Per the bail conditions, she is prohibited from possessing a firearm or dangerous weapon.

Guillette has a status conference scheduled for March 3, a pretrial conference scheduled for April 14 and a jury draw scheduled for April 18, court records indicate.

People experiencing a mental health crisis can call or text the National Suicide & Crisis Lifeline at 988 for immediate support.

If you or a loved one feel unsafe at home, the National Domestic Violence Hotline offers immediate resources and help at thehotline.org or by calling 1-800-799-SAFE (7233). In the Upper Valley, you can reach the WISE Crisis Line at 866-348-9473 or visit wiseuv.org.

Sofia Langlois can be reached at slanglois@vnews.com or 603-727-3242.